Saturday, July 05, 2008 ..:: Home ::.. Register  Login
Blog roll

Topic search

Announcements
This site is picking up steam - Friday, May 02, 2008

This site is picking up steam in terms of content with both Justin James and George Ou cranking out daily blogs.  We're in the process of getting rid of ForMortals.com and redirecting it to www.ForMortals.com along with some other SEO things that need to be done.

 

UsersOnline
Membership Membership:
Latest New User Latest: JetJaguar
New Today New Today: 0
New Yesterday New Yesterday: 0
User Count Overall: 97

People Online People Online:
Visitors Visitors: 0
Members Members: 0
Total Total: 0

Online Now Online Now:

New_Blog
You must be logged in and have permission to create or edit a blog.

Blogs
May 20

Written by: George Ou
5/20/2008 4:48 PM

 

I never liked the design of the original OLPC XO laptop, but the design of the XO-2 looks fantastic and very futuristic.  It looks like two oversized iPhones connected in a clamshell design and it's using a soft touch-screen keyboard.  It can be used in vertical book mode or in laptop mode with a virtual keyboard.

The problem is that Nicholas Negroponte still hasn't learned from his original mistakes of over promising and under delivering.  He promised an instant booting instant loading laptop for $100 and he delivered a $200 (at quantities of 10000) laptop that took more than 3 minutes to boot and a minute to load applications.  While the original XO has switched to a workable platform with Microsoft Windows XP and Microsoft Office, the cost remains high and problems with the keyboard persists.  Now Mr. Negroponte is promising a price of $75 for the XO-2 with a delivery date of 2010 but it's hard to take his promises seriously.  In fact I'll come up with the following formula.

Negroponte pricing = 0.5 x BOM (QTY 10000) pricing

The XO-2 may avoid the mechanical failure problem in the original XO rubberized keyboards by getting rid of a mechanical keyboard altogether, but the XO will go from inadequate tactile feedback to zero tactile feedback.  That may not be a problem for casual typing and there won't be any failed sticky rubber keys.  The touch-screen keyboard hasn't held back the wild success of the Apple iPhone but that's because it probably is the best soft-key system ever implemented and the other benefits of the iPhone outweigh the disadvantages.

The bigger question for the XO-2 (or devices like it) is whether it will come close to the high bar set by Apple's iPhone.  The responsiveness of the animated and natural interface on the iPhone is not only revolutionary for Smartphones, but it puts the Windows and Mac OS X interface to shame.  For a device like this to succeed in the market place, it must be an instant-on device with instant-load applications.

As for the CPU, it may use the second generation Intel Atom CPU codenamed "Moorestown" due in 2009 which has a TDP of less than a watt including the chipset or perhaps the successor to Moorestown" in 2010.  But the raw costs of the parts alone will be more than $100 even in 2010 but then again, $100 is $50 if you're using pie-in-the-sky Negroponte pricing.

If the XO-2 or a similar device can come anywhere close to an iPhone experience, then it will succeed in the developed world as a $200 device in and outside of the education market.  Just don't count on this succeeding in the third world any time soon unless someone has a lot of money to donate because no country will spend the annual salary of their adults on laptops for their children or even a fraction of that.

Tags:

10 comments so far...

Looks nice, but......

[i]While the original XO has switched to a workable platform with Microsoft Windows XP and Microsoft Office[/i]

I disagree with your claim that the original XO has switched to a workable platform. The plat form with Windows and Office has now been doomed to failure. Microsoft had a chance to get into this project at the beginning, and poo-pooed the project. Now that they saw their mistake, they have poisoned the project with an unworkable OS.

The project is now destined to fail. Too bad for the intended recipients.

By linuxforme on   5/20/2008 7:42 PM

What about the 3 minute boot times in the Sugar OS version?

What about the 3 minute boot times in the Sugar OS version and the long application load times? What about the unworkable 802.11s stack? What about the limited childish interface? How is that even remotely workable?

Windows XP booting in 50 seconds and having a usable MS Office on the machine makes it fairly usable if you can get past the keyboard problems.

By host on   5/20/2008 7:44 PM

Re: OLPC XO-2 looks nice, but will it materialize at $75 or even twice that?

I would love to see this device at $200, I'd buy one just to keep in the car or toss in a backpack for day trips and such.

J.Ja

By jmjames on   5/20/2008 8:42 PM

Only if the OS isn't clunky and limited like Sugar OS and it's implemented as well as the iPhone.

Only if the OS isn't clunky and limited like Sugar OS and it's implemented as well as the iPhone. If that's the case, then the device would actually sell for $300 in the free market.

By host on   5/20/2008 9:01 PM

Re: OLPC XO-2 looks nice, but will it materialize at $75 or even twice that?

Looks great. Put Windows XP on it and I'm right there!

Heck, Windows Mobile 6 would be sufficient!

By rlbs56 on   5/21/2008 4:45 AM

Looks great except....

If they couldn't get the $100 mark with the old system, what will allow them to get to the $75 mark with the OLPC 2.

Many of the ULPC models aren't even close to hitting that mark and they don't look nearly as advanced.

Ideas?

By nuCrash on   5/21/2008 7:29 AM

Of course it's possible nuCrash, just look at my formula for Negorponte pricing

Negroponte pricing = 0.5 x BOM (QTY 10000) pricing. So if Negroponte promises $75 in 2010, that means it will be available in 2011 with an actual wholesale pricing at quantity 10000 of $150. That translates to a retail price of $250.

By host on   5/21/2008 9:03 PM

Re: OLPC XO-2 looks nice, but will it materialize at $75 or even twice that?

Looks like they combined the iPhone screen with the Nintendo DS form factor, sort of.
Looks interesting. Wonder if they are thinking about using eInk for the keyboard side?

By xwindowsjunkie on   5/25/2008 4:52 AM

Re: OLPC XO-2 looks nice, but will it materialize at $75 or even twice that?

This would be wonderful for moms to have in the car to keep children occupied on long trips.

By jane1958 on   6/20/2008 10:09 AM

A $70 DVD player in the car works pretty well for the kids too, so long as you have a movie they like

A $70 DVD player in the car works pretty well for the kids too, so long as you have a movie they like. When we do the long road trips to vacation, that DVD player is a must.

By host on   6/20/2008 10:12 AM

Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Add Comment    Cancel  

Links

Blog_Archive

Search_Blog

Note to readers

Readers who log in will be able to post comments without approval.  Anonymous posts will require my approval.


Copyright 2008 by George Ou or Justin James   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement